MCCQE1 practice questions: the duties that override confidentiality in Canada
Three full clinical vignettes with worked explanations. Confidentiality is the rule and the exceptions are specific. The one candidates most often get wrong is the duty to warn — because the case they are thinking of is American, and Canadian law reached a different place.
These are free samples. The full platform builds papers from the Canadian guidelines, grades them, and tracks every topic you get wrong.
Three kinds of exception, and they behave differently
"When may I break confidentiality?" is really three separate questions with three different answers. Keeping them apart is most of the work.
Mandatory, discretionary, and permitted
| Situation | What the law does |
|---|---|
| A child who may be in need of protection | Mandatory across Canada. Taking Ontario's statute as the worked example, all three of
the features that get examined are written into it. The threshold is reasonable grounds
to suspect, not proof. The duty is personal: the reporter shall make the report directly to the society and shall not rely on any other person to report on the person's behalf. And it is ongoing — a person with additional grounds shall make a further report … even if the person has made previous reports with respect to the same child. One limit worth knowing: in Ontario the mandatory duty does not apply to a child who is 16 or 17, though a report may still be made. |
| Reportable communicable disease | Mandatory, under each province's or territory's public health legislation, to the local medical officer of health. The list of diseases is set provincially. |
| Fitness to drive | Varies by province, and it is not a clean two-way split. Four patterns: Mandatory — Saskatchewan, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador, the Northwest Territories, Yukon and Nunavut (in Manitoba and Yukon, where the patient is of driving age and holds a valid licence). Mixed — Ontario: mandatory for the conditions on the Ministry of Transportation's list, and discretionary for conditions outside it. Discretionary — Alberta, Nova Scotia and Quebec; though in Quebec the Collège des médecins takes the view that a physician must report where a patient is likely to keep driving despite a warning and poses a serious risk to public safety. Conditional — British Columbia: reporting becomes mandatory only if the patient continues to drive after being warned not to. Reporting in good faith is generally protected. |
| A threat to an identifiable person | A permission, not a duty. The Supreme Court of Canada in Smith v. Jones (1999)
recognised a public safety exception to confidentiality. As the CMPA puts the test,
imminent and serious danger to the safety of an identifiable person or group of people can be sufficient justification. Disclose the minimum needed to address the risk, not the chart. The CPSO states there is no mandatory legal duty to warn in Ontario — which does not mean a physician should do nothing. |
The American Tarasoff line of cases created a duty to protect. Canada did not adopt it. If your instinct is "I must warn, or I will be liable", that instinct was trained on the wrong country.
Three practice questions
A 41-year-old man being treated for a depressive episode tells you during a consultation in Ontario that he has been having detailed thoughts of seriously harming his former business partner, whom he names and whose workplace he describes. He says he has thought about how he would do it and has considered when the man is usually alone. He is not psychotic and does not meet the criteria for involuntary admission. Which of the following best reflects the legal position in Canada?
- A. You are legally required to warn the named person, as established by Tarasoff
- B. Disclosure to protect the identified person is permitted under the public safety exception; there is no general mandatory duty to warn in Ontario
- C. Confidentiality is absolute, and disclosure would be a breach in all circumstances
- D. You may disclose only with a court order
- E. You must report the conversation to the police, who then decide whether to warn him
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: B. Disclosure to protect the identified person is permitted under the public safety exception; there is no general mandatory duty to warn in Ontario
The Supreme Court of Canada in Smith v. Jones recognised that danger to public safety can justify disclosing otherwise confidential information without consent. The decision is usually summarised as three factors: how clear the risk is, how serious the threatened harm is, and how imminent it is — with the risk running to an identifiable person or group. The CMPA states the threshold as imminent and serious danger to the safety of an identifiable person or group of people
. This stem gives you all of it: a named target, serious harm, and planning.
What the Court did not do is create an American-style duty. The CPSO states plainly that there is no mandatory legal duty to warn in Ontario. So disclosure here is something you may do, in the exercise of judgement, not something the law commands you to do.
In practice the answer is rarely just "warn or don't". You document carefully, consider the clinical response to the risk, take advice — the CMPA exists for precisely this call — and disclose no more than is necessary to address the danger. That last point matters: the exception justifies proportionate disclosure, not handing over the chart.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. Tarasoff is a California case and the duty it created is American. Citing it as binding Canadian authority is the characteristic error on this topic.
- C. Confidentiality is a strong rule with recognised exceptions, not an absolute. The public safety exception is one of them.
- D. A court order is not a precondition. The exception operates without one, which is the point of having it for situations that will not wait.
- E. Involving police may well form part of a reasonable response, but the stem asks for the legal position, and there is no mandatory duty to report such a conversation.
A 3-year-old is brought to the emergency department with a spiral fracture of the humerus. The history offered is that she rolled off a sofa. You note several bruises of differing ages over the trunk, including two in a pattern you cannot account for. The explanation does not fit the injury or the child's developmental stage. You are uncertain, and the father is attentive and plausible. Which of the following is the most appropriate course of action?
- A. Report your suspicion to the child protection authority now
- B. Admit the child and report only if the skeletal survey confirms non-accidental injury
- C. Ask the hospital social worker to investigate and to make the report if they agree
- D. Discuss your concerns with the family physician before taking any further step
- E. Document your concerns and arrange close follow-up, reporting if there is a further injury
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: A. Report your suspicion to the child protection authority now
The duty to report a child who may be in need of protection arises on reasonable suspicion. You do not need to be sure, and you are not expected to investigate: deciding what happened is the child protection authority's job, not yours. A spiral fracture with an implausible mechanism, bruises of differing ages, and a history that does not fit the child's developmental stage is comfortably enough to trigger it.
Two features of this duty are examined repeatedly, and Ontario's statute spells both out. It is personal: the reporter shall make the report directly to the society and shall not rely on any other person to report on the person's behalf
. No seniority and no job title discharges it for you. And it is ongoing: a person with additional grounds shall make a further report … even if the person has made previous reports with respect to the same child
.
The father being attentive and plausible is in the stem for a reason. It is the detail most likely to talk a clinician out of a report, and it is not evidence about what happened to the child.
Why the other options are wrong
- B. The threshold is suspicion, not confirmation. Waiting for imaging to prove the case inverts the standard and delays protection.
- C. Delegating is precisely what this duty does not permit. A social worker may also have a duty; that does not discharge yours.
- D. Seeking advice is sensible in many situations but cannot substitute for a report, and the family physician has no role in authorising one.
- E. "Reporting if there is a further injury" accepts another injury as the price of certainty. That is the outcome the duty exists to prevent.
A 68-year-old man in Ontario has a first unprovoked generalised tonic-clonic seizure, and subsequent assessment supports a diagnosis of epilepsy. He holds a class G driver's licence and drives daily to visit his wife in long-term care. He tells you he understands the risk but intends to keep driving, as there is no bus route and he sees no alternative. Which of the following is the most appropriate course of action?
- A. Report to the Ministry of Transportation, as reporting is mandatory in Ontario for prescribed conditions
- B. Advise him not to drive and document the advice, but do not report, as the decision is his
- C. Report only if he has a further seizure while driving
- D. Ask his wife or family to remove his car keys instead of reporting
- E. Report to the police rather than to the licensing authority
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: A. Report to the Ministry of Transportation, as reporting is mandatory in Ontario for prescribed conditions
Ontario has a mandatory duty to report prescribed conditions and impairments that make driving dangerous, to the Ministry of Transportation. It applies even where the patient says they will not drive — and this patient has said the opposite.
Advising him and documenting the advice is necessary but not sufficient in a mandatory reporting province. The report is a legal obligation, not a judgement call, and physicians reporting in good faith are protected.
Note why this case is squarely inside the mandatory duty rather than at its edge. Ontario's duty is mandatory for the conditions the Ministry of Transportation lists, and epilepsy with a seizure is the archetype of a listed condition. That distinction matters, because Ontario is not uniformly mandatory: for conditions outside the list, reporting there is discretionary.
The provincial variation is examinable in its own right, and it is not a two-way split. Alberta, Nova Scotia and Quebec are discretionary — though Quebec's college takes the view that a physician must report a patient likely to keep driving against advice who poses a serious public-safety risk. British Columbia is conditional: a report becomes mandatory only once the patient continues to drive after being warned. The remaining provinces and territories are mandatory. So "it is the physician's discretion" is defensible in a few places and wrong here — which is why the stem names the province.
None of this means abandoning him. The loss of a licence in order to visit a spouse in care is a real harm, and addressing it — transport options, timelines for reinstatement, social work involvement — is part of the same consultation.
Why the other options are wrong
- B. This is the correct approach in a discretionary province. In Ontario it omits a legal obligation.
- C. Waiting for a seizure at the wheel accepts the collision as the trigger for preventing it.
- D. Asking family to police the situation places the burden on people with no authority, and does not discharge a statutory duty.
- E. The report goes to the licensing authority, which can act on the licence. Police are not the recipient of a fitness-to-drive report.
Four traps this topic sets
1. Importing Tarasoff. Canada has a public safety exception that permits disclosure, not an American-style duty to warn. In Ontario the College says so explicitly.
2. Waiting for proof before reporting a child. The threshold is reasonable suspicion, and investigating is somebody else's job.
3. Delegating a personal duty. Telling a senior colleague or a social worker does not discharge your obligation to report.
4. Assuming fitness-to-drive reporting is discretionary. It is mandatory in most of Canada. But resist the opposite oversimplification too: Ontario is mandatory only for the conditions on the Ministry's list and discretionary outside it, and British Columbia turns mandatory only after a warning is ignored. The province in the stem is part of the question, and sometimes so is the condition.
Sources
Every figure on this page is traceable to one of these. Guidelines are revised — open the source before you commit a number to memory.
- CMPA — Do you need to report your patient's fitness to drive? — which provinces are mandatory and which are discretionary
- CMPA — The duty to report — the reporting obligations that override confidentiality
- CPSO — Advice to the Profession: Reporting Requirements — including the statement that there is no mandatory duty to warn in Ontario
- <i>Smith v. Jones</i>, [1999] 1 SCR 455 — the Supreme Court of Canada on the public safety exception to confidentiality
- Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017 (Ontario) — the statutory duty to report a child who may be in need of protection
More free MCCQE1 practice questions
- Consent, capacity and the mature minor in CanadaNo fixed age of consent, decision-specific capacity, substitute decision-makers and prior capable wishes, and how Quebec differs.
- Hypertension under the 2025 Hypertension Canada guidelineThe 130/80 diagnostic threshold, out-of-office confirmation, when drug therapy actually starts, and the systolic target below 130.
- Gestational diabetes screening and the two Canadian threshold setsThe 50 g glucose challenge bands, the preferred and alternate 75 g OGTT criteria, and why the same blood results can produce two different diagnoses.
- Diabetes Canada: diagnosis, A1C targets and screening intervalsThe four diagnostic tests, why the target is not 7.0% for everybody, and when screening starts outside pregnancy.
See all free MCCQE1 practice topics →
About these practice pages
MCCQE1 Tutor is a Canadian-guideline preparation platform for the Medical Council of Canada Qualifying Examination Part 1, built by AYRIQ Technologies. The questions on this page were written for this page and are given away free. They are not drawn from the subscriber question bank, so working through them uses up nothing you have paid for.
Practising on Canadian numbers is the whole point. Everything here is free; the platform is where it becomes a study plan.