MCCQE1 practice questions: consent, capacity and the mature minor in Canada

Three full clinical vignettes with worked explanations. Canadian consent law is not the law you revised from an American source, and it is not uniform across the country. There is generally no fixed age of consent for medical treatment in the common law provinces — capacity is assessed, not counted in birthdays — while Quebec sets its rules out in statute.

Written by MCCQE1 Tutor editorial team, AYRIQ Technologies · Updated 16 November 2026

These are free samples. The full platform builds papers from the Canadian guidelines, grades them, and tracks every topic you get wrong.

The four principles the exam keeps returning to

1. Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific. A patient is not globally capable or incapable. They are capable, or not, with respect to this decision, now. The same patient may be capable of consenting to a blood test and incapable of weighing a thoracotomy, and a patient who was incapable last night may be capable this morning.

2. Age is not the test in most of Canada. There is no universally accepted, legally defined age of consent to medical treatment in Canada. The common law applies the mature minor doctrine. The CMPA states it this way: a young person is capable of consenting to or refusing treatment if the physical, mental, and emotional development of the person will allow for a full appreciation of the nature and consequences of the decision — and that the criterion for capacity to consent is maturity, not chronological age. A.C. v. Manitoba (2009) is the leading Canadian case on how far that doctrine reaches.

3. If the patient is capable, the consent comes from the patient. This holds even when a parent is sitting in the room, and even when the parent disagrees. Where a minor is capable with respect to a treatment, consent must be obtained from the minor directly.

4. If the patient is incapable, consent comes from a substitute decision-maker identified by the applicable provincial or territorial legislation — not from whichever relative is most available or most insistent. The substitute decides according to the patient's prior capable wishes where those are known and applicable, and otherwise in the patient's best interests.

How the provinces differ — the part no international question bank covers

JurisdictionStarting position for a minor
Ontario The Health Care Consent Act presumption of capacity applies to minors too. No minimum age. If the minor is capable with respect to that treatment, the physician must obtain consent from the minor.
Alberta The College's standard of practice puts a positive duty on the physician: for a patient under 18, determine whether the patient is a mature minor with capacity to give informed consent, and if they are not, seek consent from the legal guardian. The Canadian Paediatric Society summarises Alberta's position as a patient under 18 being presumed without capacity but open to assessment as a mature minor.
Yukon Capacity is presumed unless demonstrated otherwise, and the presumption can be rebutted by evidence of a minor's immaturity.
Prince Edward Island Every person including a minor who is capable may give or refuse consent to treatment. Note the framing: this is a capability test rather than a stated presumption of capacity regardless of age, and the difference is the sort of thing a careful question exploits.
Quebec Statutory, in the Civil Code of Québec (arts 14–18). For a minor under 14, the person having parental authority or the tutor consents. A minor 14 or over may consent alone to care required by their state of health — and in fact to care that is not required by it, except that parental or tutor consent comes back in where such care carries a serious risk to health. Where a minor 14 or over refuses care, court authorization is required, except in an emergency where life is endangered or integrity threatened — and in that emergency the effect is that the consent of a parent or tutor becomes sufficient.
Everywhere Child welfare legislation exists in every province and territory and can allow a court to override the decision of a minor in defined circumstances. A mature minor's decision is not beyond review: the majority in A.C. v. Manitoba accepted that a court may override it where it is not in the minor's best interests.

Because the rules are provincial, a well-written Canadian question tells you where it is set. If a stem names a province, that is not scene-setting — it is part of the question.

Three practice questions

Question 1 · The capable minor

A 16-year-old attends a walk-in clinic in Ontario alone, requesting testing and treatment for a suspected sexually transmitted infection. She explains the proposed treatment back to you accurately, describes its common adverse effects and what would happen if she declined, and asks sensible questions about partner notification. She asks that her parents not be contacted, and declines to give you their details. Which of the following is the most appropriate course of action?

Show the answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Obtain consent from the patient and proceed with testing and treatment

Everything in the stem is evidence of capacity: she understands the information relevant to the decision and appreciates the reasonably foreseeable consequences of consenting and of refusing. That is the test, and she meets it.

In Ontario the presumption of capacity extends to minors, and there is no minimum age. Once she is capable with respect to this treatment, the consent that matters is hers. Her confidentiality follows from the same finding: a capable patient's health information is not disclosed to a parent without the patient's consent, so contacting her parents against her wishes is a breach, not a courtesy.

Encouraging her to involve a trusted adult is good practice and entirely compatible with this answer. Making it a condition of treatment is not.

Why the other options are wrong

  • B. This imports an age of majority rule that Canadian law does not apply to treatment decisions. It is the most frequently chosen wrong answer, and it would also deter exactly the patients who most need confidential sexual health care.
  • C. Treating and then disclosing is worse than either alternative: it provides the care and breaches the confidentiality of a capable patient, who will not come back.
  • D. Court involvement is reserved for narrow circumstances, such as a refusal of necessary care in some jurisdictions, or a child welfare matter. It has no place in the routine consent of a capable patient.
  • E. Partner notification is part of her care and her decision. Splitting the consultation to route part of it through a parent she has asked you not to contact has no legal or clinical basis.
Guideline anchor: Ontario Health Care Consent Act, as described in the CPSO guide: the presumption of capacity applies regardless of age, and where a minor is capable with respect to a treatment, consent is obtained from the minor. CMPA: a mature minor is one whose physical, mental and emotional development allows a full appreciation of the nature and consequences of the decision.
Question 2 · The incapable adult and a prior wish

An 82-year-old woman with advanced dementia is admitted with aspiration pneumonia and is assessed as incapable with respect to decisions about feeding. Two years ago, while clearly capable, she told her family physician and her daughter that she would not want to be fed through a tube if she reached a stage where she no longer recognised her family; this was documented in her chart at the time. Her daughter, who is her substitute decision-maker, now asks that a feeding tube be inserted, saying she cannot bear to watch her mother decline. In a province with health care consent legislation of the Ontario type, which of the following best describes the obligation here?

Show the answer and explanation

Correct answer: B. The substitute decision-maker must act on the patient's prior capable wish that applies to these circumstances

A substitute decision-maker is not a free agent. The role is to give the decision the patient would have given. Where there is a prior capable wish that applies to the circumstances, the substitute is bound by it; best interests is the standard used only when no applicable prior wish is known.

Her wish here is unusually clean: she was capable when she expressed it, it was expressed to two people including her physician, it was documented, and the condition she described — no longer recognising her family — is the situation that has now arrived. That is a wish that applies.

The right response to the daughter is not to override her, but to explain the role she holds: she is being asked to convey her mother's decision, not to make her own. Where a substitute cannot or will not act consistently with a prior capable wish, the relevant provincial body can be engaged — in Ontario, the Consent and Capacity Board, which can also appoint a representative to give or refuse consent.

Practical note: the specifics of how binding a prior expressed wish is, and of who ranks as substitute decision-maker, are set by provincial and territorial statute and vary. The principle that a substitute decides for the patient rather than for themselves does not.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This confuses authority with discretion. The daughter does hold the authority to give or refuse consent, and must exercise it according to her mother's known wishes rather than her own.
  • C. The physician's view of best interests does not displace either the substitute decision-maker or a prior capable wish. Clinical judgement shapes what is offered, not who consents.
  • D. Court involvement is a last resort. Nothing here is in dispute as a matter of law; what is needed is a conversation about the substitute's role.
  • E. The opposite is true. A prior capable wish matters precisely because the patient is now incapable; if incapacity extinguished it, advance care planning would be pointless.
Guideline anchor: CMPA: many jurisdictions have legislation governing consent from a substitute decision-maker when a patient lacks capacity. CPSO guide to the Ontario Health Care Consent Act: a substitute decision-maker follows the patient's prior capable wishes where applicable, and otherwise acts in the patient's best interests; the Consent and Capacity Board may appoint a representative.
Question 3 · Refusal by a minor in Quebec

A 15-year-old in Montreal is admitted with a haemoglobin of 58 g/L from a severe but not immediately life-threatening gastrointestinal bleed that has now stopped. Transfusion is clearly indicated. She understands the recommendation and the consequences of declining, and refuses transfusion. Her parents support transfusing her. She is haemodynamically stable and there is time to act deliberately. Under the law of Quebec, which of the following is correct?

Show the answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. Court authorization is required to transfuse her over her refusal, as this is not an emergency

Quebec is the jurisdiction most often answered wrongly, because candidates learn one half of its rule. The Civil Code of Québec does allow a minor 14 or over to consent alone to care required by their state of health. But consent and refusal are treated differently: where a minor 14 or over refuses care, court authorization is required, except in an emergency where life is endangered or integrity is threatened — and in that emergency what the exception actually does is make the consent of a parent or tutor sufficient, rather than dispensing with consent altogether.

The stem has been built to close off the emergency route deliberately: the bleeding has stopped, she is haemodynamically stable, and there is time. So the answer is neither to accept her refusal as final nor to transfuse on her parents' consent, but to seek the court's authorization — while continuing to support her, monitor her, and keep discussing it with her and her family.

Contrast the common law provinces, where a mature minor's refusal carries considerable weight but is still open to review by a court on best-interests grounds, as the majority accepted in A.C. v. Manitoba. The destination is similar; the route and the presumptions differ.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. This is the half-remembered rule. The Civil Code provision on consenting alone at 14 does not carry across to refusing needed care, which is specifically made subject to court authorization.
  • B. Parental consent does not override the refusal of a minor 14 or over in Quebec. Her age puts her inside the Civil Code provisions, not outside them.
  • D. The emergency exception is the one route the stem has removed. Reaching for it when the bleeding has stopped and the patient is stable is the error the question is testing.
  • E. A concurring clinical opinion confirms that transfusion is indicated. It does not supply the legal authority to give it over a refusal.
Guideline anchor: Civil Code of Québec, arts 14–18, as summarised by the Canadian Paediatric Society: consent to care for a minor under 14 is given by the person having parental authority or the tutor; a minor 14 or over may consent alone; court authorization is necessary to submit a minor 14 or over to care that they refuse, except in emergency cases where life is endangered or integrity threatened, when the consent of a parent or tutor is sufficient. We were not able to open the Civil Code itself to pin the rule to a single article number — read the articles at the Quebec government source below.

Four traps this topic sets

1. Answering with an age. In most of Canada there is no age of consent to treatment. If your reasoning ends at "she is under 18", you have skipped the assessment the law actually requires.

2. Treating capacity as a global property. Capacity attaches to a decision at a point in time. A finding of incapacity for one decision, or last week, does not settle this one.

3. Reading consent and refusal as symmetrical. They often are not, in Quebec by statute and in the common law provinces through the courts' best-interests jurisdiction. A stem that switches from consenting to refusing has changed the question.

4. Letting the most insistent relative decide. A substitute decision-maker is identified by legislation and bound by the patient's prior capable wishes. Distress is a reason for support, not a source of authority.

A note on provincial variation

Consent is provincial and territorial law, and this page describes general principles plus named examples. Before relying on any of it in practice, read the statute and the college guidance for the jurisdiction you are licensed in: Ontario's Health Care Consent Act, Alberta's standards of practice, the Civil Code of Québec, and the equivalents elsewhere do not say the same thing. The CMPA's own advice, when a patient may be a mature minor or where capacity is in question, is to consult a colleague or to call them.

Sources

Every figure on this page is traceable to one of these. Guidelines are revised — open the source before you commit a number to memory.

  1. CMPA — Informed consent — the mature minor definition and substitute decision-maker guidance
  2. CPSO — Guide to the Health Care Consent Act (Ontario) — presumption of capacity, minors, and the Consent and Capacity Board
  3. CPSA — Informed Consent standard of practice (Alberta) — the rebuttable presumption that a patient under 18 lacks capacity
  4. Civil Code of Québec (official text, arts 14–18) — the statutory rules for minors consenting to and refusing care — read the articles directly
  5. Canadian Bar Association — Competence, Capacity and Consent — A.C. v. Manitoba and the limits of the mature minor principle
  6. Canadian Paediatric Society — Medical decision-making in paediatrics: infancy to adolescence — developmental assessment of a minor's decision-making

More free MCCQE1 practice questions

See all free MCCQE1 practice topics →

About these practice pages

MCCQE1 Tutor is a Canadian-guideline preparation platform for the Medical Council of Canada Qualifying Examination Part 1, built by AYRIQ Technologies. The questions on this page were written for this page and are given away free. They are not drawn from the subscriber question bank, so working through them uses up nothing you have paid for.

Practising on Canadian numbers is the whole point. Everything here is free; the platform is where it becomes a study plan.